gdeering.com

Gary's Venns

Not Zen, but Venn. Venn and the Art of Person Maintenance.

Unpublished letters / Viewpoint: a challenge isn't scientific (July 2003)

Viewpoint: a challenge isn't scientific (July 2003)

OPION PAGES
St. Paul Pioneer Press
Fax: 651-228-5564
email: letters@pioneerpress.com
Faxed & emailed: July 29, 2003

[not, i.e. written but not sent, see sent version in "Dunno, maybe"]

VIEWPOINT

     A challenge isn’t scientific just because it’s a challenge nor is a question “scientific” just because it’s a question (as suggested by Guest Columnist David E. Stoltzman’s July 27 article that intelligent design is a legitimate scientific challenge to evolution). A challenge (or question) is scientific (that is, rational) if and only if it is based on the evidence of our senses and/or on valid --non-contradictory-- concepts derived from evidence based on the senses. For example, we know from our observations of eyes, optic nerves and brains that eyesight is a very complex function (as D. Stoltzman properly points out in his article). From this and other complex things that we can and do observe first hand in reality we rationally can conclude that: complexity exists inside the Universe. But to leap from this to: therefore, the Universe exists inside of complexity, is not warranted; it is no more warranted nor any less valid than trying to argue that since all men are mortal, all mortals are men. Such an unwarranted leap cannot be legitimately made using reason; it can only be illegitimately made using faith.

     This is why reason is better than faith: it –reason—prevents your thoughts and ideas from being promiscuous with each other in such a way as to inadvertently give birth to illegitimate concepts and conclusions. Faith’s middle name, on the other hand, is, nymphomaniac, a nymphomaniac with the propensity for popping out illegitimate concepts and conclusions with a rapidity that would make machine-gun designers get up off their elbows and take notes.

     Evolutionists --as scientists-- offer us lay people layer upon layer of sensory evidence and reasons in the form of layer upon layer of fossil records and other built up non-contradictory-as-best-as-they-can-make-them concepts for their theory of evolution. A theory with concepts that appeal to our ability to reason not to our “ability” to accept assertions based on faith, assertions such as the erroneous one that says all questions are scientific simply because they are questions. There is no evidence to conclude that this assertion is true so if one does accept it, it can only be done on faith (see story of the doubting Thomas in The Holy Bible for an example of the “virtue” and hence of the motivation for accepting ideas without evidence). The evolutionists do not ask us lay people to take them on faith but rather to take them on reason.

     The intelligent designer advocates (since the time of the Catholic Church’s best, Thomas Aquinas) on the other hand offer only authoritarian “challenges” by saying that faith based concepts and conclusions are as good as reason based ones (since 9/11/01 they no longer argue that faith is better than reason and this is an improvement). Then the intelligent designer advocates --as faith promoters—think they don’t have to give valid evidence and rational, non-contradictory arguments for their views. All they have to do, they think, is “challenge” some scientists view with their appeal to: who besides losers and non-believers need evidence; all challenges and/or questions are rational (scientific) simply because they are challenges and/or questions.

     For an example of a faith based concept consider in the Stolzman article he uses (that is, he makes the same mistake that evolutionists do in using) randomness to be a metaphysical concept when in fact it is an epistemological one. That is, randomness as used in evolutionary theory and the Stolzman article is a measure of the degree to which non-omniscient man currently understands --or more precisely-- does not fully understand the things –e.g., evolutionary theory—he claims to fully understand. When a person or a scientist involkes “randomness” as an “explainer” he is simply saying, I don’t understand the natural processes and/or cause-effect relationships any deeper than that which I have proved so far. Since man is not omniscient it is OK for him to involk randomness –backed up by some statistics as placeholder—as an epistemological device and one that should be recognized as a shortcoming to be filled in by some future rational thinker.

     So if it is the case that any challenge is scientific simply because it is a challenge --which of course it isn’t, but if you are going to be consistent on your own terms-- then I challenge intelligent design advocates to disprove the following scientific challenge. Since all things are created, god too was created and he was created by the devil.

     And before people start accusing me of advocating this last as anything other than a test for the religious mind to test its own intellectual honesty, let me point out that as a by-product of the philosophy I have consciously accepted (Objectivism) I am an (ex-Lutheran god-believer turned) atheist.

Gary Deering
My address
my phone number, myemail@myISP

Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh.