Unpublished letters / Is Morality without Religion Possible?
Is Morality without Religion Possible?
St. Paul Pioneer Press
Fax: 651-228-5564
June 28, 2002
VIEWPOINT
Is Morality without Religiion Possible?
The short answer is: No.
The intermediary answer is: Yes and no.
The long answer is: Yes.
The answers in order.
Short: no.
No, that is, if one believes that morality is a code of conduct derived from the belief that a god and/or gods exist.
Intermediary: yes and no.
Yes, if one believes that morality is a code of conduct based on the fact that human beings need morality as much as they need food.
Or, to be more precise, yes if one believes that morality is to human consciousness what dietary rules are to the human body: without them one stands a good chance of poisoning one's self.
And no, as previously described.
Long: yes.
Yes if, one believes that morality is a rule book in the brain for how one is suppose to behave when alone by one's self (pick some berries and eat or die) and/or when one is with others (don't write challenging Viewpoint Articles if you don't want religious fundamentalist-nuts stalking you).
Or --to be more precise-- yes if, one believes that morality is a code of internalized values that one uses to guide ones life, which means to guide ones choices and actions in order to achieve the internalized goals one has set for oneself.
For example: if one has set the goal: get to heaven, then one has to figure out what it takes to get-to-heaven. Then one internalizes these "things", these values and then when faced with a choice, one makes the choice based on ones understanding of the rules, that is, the rule book, that is, the moral code one has put inside one's own psyche.
For example, there is one prerequisite to getting into heaven that is universal to all religions and hence it is shared by all religious people regardless of specific religion. This prerequisite is: you have to be dead before you can go to heaven. Live people do not go to heaven. So, should I kill myself right now so I can go to heaven right now or should I not, should I wait? Perhaps, those who say that the act of killing oneself --itself-- precludes entry into heaven. Or rather, what if they are right? I'd better wait and do some more checking.
Now, whether one has put the "rules" there --in one's own psyche-- by choice or by osmosis doesn't alter the fact that one put them their by choice even if one made this choice by letting ones consciousness act like a sponge --be it a sponge sopping up cultural truths or one sopping up cultural bromides, or both.
The reason we believe this latter position is because we all know on some level of our being that human beings do not act --with one and only one exception-- humans do not act against their own judgment. That is, adult human beings don't. Children are a little bit of a different issue, but we are here talking about adults --self-responsible adults and-- so we continue on assuming that self-responsible adults are the ones to whom the question is addressed.
The one exception to the "human beings do not act against their own judgment" premise of course is: physical coercion. If someone puts a gun to my head and says "give me the keys to your car, or I'll pull the trigger", I act against my better judgment: I would never in a million, billion, gazillion years voluntarily give my keys to a car thief and would be murderer.
But notice that even here a kind of choice is involved. When evil threatens my life I choose to act against my own --normal-- judgment and turn over a value to its demands.
Why do I do this?
Because no value is higher to me than my own life. My car for sure is not more valuable to me than is my life.
So I turn my car keys over to evil and hope the rest of the people in my community empathize with me and agree with me that the moral-code-of-a-criminal is not the proper moral code for us to adopt (and call ourselves civilized at the same time). And more: that the proper moral conduct here is to do our best to track down that criminal and bring her (or him) to justice by punishing them in a way that is commensurate with the crime.
And notice how quickly our minds work and because of it we have already gone beyond the original question and are now into a new question and so we must stop, least we write forever.
The new question is: Is a proper morality possible without Religion?
Since this is a different question and I need to end here, I permit myself the short answer.
Short:
It is the only way it is possible.
Gary Deering, retired psychotherapist and freelance writer
My address
my phone number, myemail@myISP
Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh.