gdeering.com

Gary's Venns

Not Zen, but Venn. Venn and the Art of Person Maintenance.

Unpublished letters / Moral War not Religious War

Moral War not Religious War

From: gary
Date: Wednesday, November 27, 2002 9:38 AM
To: oped@nytimes.com
Subject: Moral War not Religious War

NY TIMES Op-Ed:

OPINION

Moral War not Religious War

In the absence of clear cut evidence, albeit not in the absence of any evidence (Saddam Hussein has a demonstrated track record of thuggery), but in the absence of clear cut, first hand I’ve-been-there-and-seen-it-for-myself evidence, we American citizens have a very difficult moral decision to make in regards to our country’s possible declaration of war against Iraqians for their failure to dispose of a tyrant.

That moral decision is this: we have to decide if we are going to hold the people of Iraq morally responsible for their leaders.

On the surface of course this sounds like a no-brainer: of course people are responsible for their leaders, for examples see America’s Revolutionary War or the movie, "BRAVEHEART", or both. Nonetheless, since our opinions run the risk of being only surface, we know --as responsible adults and citizens-- that things often times are more complicated than we first imagine.

For example, there is a philosophical assertion that says: "morality stops at the point of a gun". Because of this assertion it is difficult (albeit not impossible) to judge the individual Iraqians as immoral for not disposing of their tyrant long ago. They have had ample time to do it but they have not done so. In fact the opposite has happened: their tyrant –under the protective cover of Iraqian inaction-- has been able to flourish and grow in his potential to destroy individual rights everywhere, not just inside Iraq. And since that everywhere now includes –as demonstrated by the facts of September 11th, 2001-- the United States of America, we Americans are faced with proving the truth of another assertion –also made by the philosophy of Objectivism-- that claims the United States of America is the most moral nation on earth.

So if this is true, we must ask: since (some) Iraqians themselves are being held at the point of a gun by their dictator Saddam Hussein, how can we hold them morally responsible in the face of that philosophical principle that says morality stops at the point of a gun?

Truth is we can't, but what we can do is consider adding an addendum to our principle. An addendum that goes like this: morality stops at the point of a gun, but heroes don't.

Neither do villains.

Both act and history writes their epitaph.

I think Iraq should be taken down next and after that perhaps Iran.

Or vice versa: the actual priority here is up to our --moral-we-hope in addition to the intelligent-we-can-observe-- military and governmental leaders.

Individual Iraqi citizens may be cowards because they do not worship individual rights, but that does not mean that all individual human beings do not worship the individual’s right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

That Americans do (or did) is the no-brainer, "obvious" sought after conclusion referred to earlier –why else do you think America’s best philosopher from the last century made that claim about us as most moral nation on earth?

Our job now is to live up to that philosopher’s praise and in-the-process make it a personally owned and culturally protected pride.

 
Gary Deering
My address
my phone number, myemail@myISP

Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh.