Unpublished letters / Viewpoint: an atheist on religion
Viewpoint: an atheist on religion
St. Paul Pioneer Press
345 Cedar Street
Fax: 651-228-5564
August 16, 2002
Dear Editor:
As a byproduct of the philosophy that I have consciously chosen to guide my life, I am --to repeat, as a byproduct-- an atheist.
As an atheist I rarely pass on an opportunity to criticize religion as same is clothed in Christian clothing by pointing out to them --through the many opportunities they themselves provide to have it pointed out to them-- the errors of their ways.
But this time --fair play demands-- I have to give credit where credit is due and this I do by saying "they" --as represented by the "Christian" clothed in the Family Policy Network "they"-- are right.
They are right --morally, ethically, practically, politically, economically or in almost any way you care to characterize it, they are absolutely right-- to use our court system to stop the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill from being the public institutional equivalent of a dork. (Since we are our public institutions this ultimately means stopping us from becoming dorks too). Since a dork is a person who through his or her own self-imposed limitations can't see the big picture, the comparison fits UNC. The big picture (somebody should tell UNC) is that individuals --not institutions, but individuals-- have rights and these rights are protected --not given, but protected-- by our Constitution. So when UNC thought it could force all its students (even those who had no interest in and never planned on attending any classes on religion) to read professor Michael A. Sells' book ("Approaching the Quran: The Early Revelations") about the Islam religion, UNC entered dorkdom. Or perhaps we should say, dork-dumb: the ill-advised educationwise do not have a monopoly on stupidity, just as those who are employees of State education institutions such as UNC are not exempt from stupidity's ravages.
There are some who will say that the Public Intellectuals in our public institutions are anything but dumb or stupid. They will say that these Public Intellectuals know exactly what they are doing and that the Chapel Hill incident was nothing more than a trial balloon to see just how much they could get away with.
Well if this is the case then I think we all owe the FPN a nod of thanks for balloon popping --thanks FPN.
The Family Policy Network --in this instance-- by protecting their right, as individual religious/Christian sympathizers, to be treated fairly and consistently by their own government are also protecting my individual right to expect and demand the same consistency treatment from my own government. A government which in this case is the same, exact, Separation-of-state-and-(EVERY)-religion Government as that of the Family Policy Network's members.
Again thank you guys for this one, but least you think I'm softening on religion I remind you to remember that since I personally think Islam is worse than Christianity --in a worst of two evils sort of way-- I am not softening. I am against ALL religion, not just the evil Islamic types and its apologizers --e.g. Clarence Page, syndicated columnist-author of "What's the harm in requiring students to read about Islam?", Pioneer Press Opinion piece, 14 August, 2002-- who are sympathetic to them.
Gary Deering, retired Engineer, freelance writer
My address
My phone number, Myemail@myISP
Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh.