More writing / Chapter 7: Know Your Opponents
Chapter 7: Know Your Opponents
Chapter 7: Know Your Opponents
O
n Wednesday June 2nd a powerful opponent took to the field. Jane Brody, a journalist turned nutrition writer and advocate of the traditional food pyramid, came out strongly against low carbohydrate diets. In addition --if you read between the lines-- you can see she is an advocate of "good" protein, which by her definition is not animal protein.She claims Atkins high protein, low fat diet is meat-loving and that few people can eat endless amounts of animal protein. She states that diets that advocate reduced carbohydrates, medium protein and medium fat are almost criminal and should come with an Attorney Generals warning. She sings the same old song that all that matters are calories: reduce calories and weight control is achieved. Her statement that Atkin's plan requires people to eat in peculiar ways does not acknowledge that her diet plans requires you to eat in peculiar ways too. Why does this alledged expert feel that low or no fat is healthy? That vegetable protein is superior to animal protein, that carbohydrates (sugar) are good for you and that fiber is eliminated on lower carbohydrate diets, such as The Zone and Protein Power? Actually, Protein Power encourages you to eat fiber.
The Atkins diet is a deprivation diet which in my estimation is not good but so is Jane Brody's low calorie, high carbohydrate "sensible" eating plan.
Deprivation diets by definition always require you to give up foods and --in some expert's minds-- the more unnatural the eating system the better they are for you.
It is peculiar to me that an alleged nutrition expert would advocate that 50-60% of your daily caloric intake come from sugar (see Protein Power's assertion that carbohydrate is just another word for sugar), 20% from protein (vegetable being superior to animal) and 20% from fat. It is known and Jane Brody acknowledges that fats and proteins have a natural ability to make you feel full and satisfied. So by depriving your self of protein and fat and increasing carbohydrates you will feel hungry, less satisfied and will probably experience cravings. In addition, because carbohydrates dull your taste buds you will probably eat more. Finally, because this is not a natural way to eat you will not be able to maintain the deprivation diet and will ultimately gain weight.
And of course such weight gain will be the fault of the dieter not of the expert who is advocating that all you have to do to control your weight is count calories.
Let your own body be the judge.
A person will not feel well when they remove fat from their diet. In order to obtain adequate protein without eating animal protein it is necessary to focus tremendous amounts of time and energy on just meal planning or to supplement your macronutrients with protein drinks or bars. In addition, who thinks that it its really beneficial to start your day off with a cup of sugar.
A Low to Moderate carbohydrate diet does not require you to give up anything. It allows you, the individual, to make choices that keeps carbohydrates on a daily basis in a target range. Nothing is forbidden and it gently nudges you towards eating natural and Healthy. It steers you away from all the Low fat tasteless junk food that is high in calories and loaded with sugar and should have a label that reads: "Gain weight easily - eat Low Fat Snacks.
The real argument with this article is that all food is made up of three components: fats, proteins, and carbohydrates. The balance of the three in a healthy diet are what the experts are fighting over. Ms. Brody is not truthful in not admitting that she is absolutely anti-animal protein which is a political decision not a diet decision. The fact that the title of a book of hers is "Jane Brody's Good Food Book, Living the High-Carbohydrate Way" should leave no doubt in your mind that she is not a disinterested objective nutrition "expert" willing to look at reduced carbohydrate diets rationally.
She's old news, old ideas, old values, and WRONG.
By Coaches assistant and Left Guard(ian)
Mary Deering
* * *
Karmelcorn™ Woman
By the teams Right guard(ian),
Gary Deering
As the Sample Weekly Food Chart in Appendix A shows my starting weight was 198 pounds. This weight was with some clothes on at our official weigh in place --The Minnetonka Marsh-- whereas at my own house with no clothes on and on a 22 year old scale it was 196 pounds ( and on subsequent "weighings" there was more like a 3 to 4 pound "variance" between the Marsh's scale and my scale).
If at this point you're thinking, "Jesus, though he's 5'7" now and weighs just under 200 pounds, when he graduated from high school 36 years ago he was 5'4" and weighed 155 pounds no wonder he's going on a "diet". If we stretch it to the extreem --which is ok to do for motivational purposes-- he is almost 33% (200-150/150) overweight! To repeat, no wonder he's going on a diet.
And further if you're thinking --as I was going into this diet thing-- that there's no way in hell I'm going to be able to go without "sweets" and all the good times and easy meals that I've had over the years and also there ain't no way I can drink 64 ounces of water a day and thank god "they" count coffee and I'm not sure I want to do this. If you are thinking something like this, then you are thinking exactly like I was going into this diet. Though I did think about these things before committing to the group and had pre-decided that I could and would overcome them, they were still a source of concern to me.
But now, here "we" are. It's the end of the second week of the "diet" and "we're" sorta doing ok. We lost 9 pounds that first week and feel pumped eventhough "they" say, men always loose like this plus it's all water weight. To which I say, who the f___ cares. I need motivation here more than I need "lectures" about why I can't succeed, why I can't win, why its a hopeless endeavor. If you believe all the cultural messages that you'll just loose a bunch of weight and then some months or years later you'll just put it all back on again, etcetera and so on and so forth. The "cultural" messages are clear: when it comes to The Diet Game you can't win, you're a looser...eventually if not immediately.
Why do "they" say this?
And who's they anyway?
Besides that first week was kinda easy anyway.
As if an ominous statement out of somekind of Stephen King novel he should never have utter this last statement.
Unbeknownst to him at the time he was on the verge of meeting his first real opponent and finding out an answer to the "why do they say this?" question.
Our coach Pamela had taken it upon herself to design the weekly input and output correspondence that each team player would follow and fax back to her after she faxed the weekly reports to us. Again, for samples of these refer to Appendix A. At the end of the first week she faxed one of these over and below is the exerpted question page that she had included for this, the second week.
Each team member was to answer these and fax them back the next upcoming Tuesday (we just happen to start our first meeting on a Tuesday, so we kept this as our weekly marker).
Week #2 Questions
Protein Power Review, FYI
Temptation vs. You (page 212)
Name__________
Fill in the Blanks and fax back to me on Tues. Mar. 16 along with your Weekly Progress Report for Week 2.
- The four components of any behavior are--
Of these four components, the one you have complete control over is__________________ and partial control over____________.
2. Seeing and smelling your temptation (in this case MAPLE doughnuts Gary) starts your __________________ working and the following changes in your body occur:
3. We must not let our _____________ and ________________ components run over our __________________ and _____________________ components.
4. We can gain control of a tempting situation by:
5. A temptation I'm frequently confronted with that I consistently control is:
6. And the way I control it is:
To which I gave (see below) "textbook" answers. Since I have a Master's Degree (from an accredited school, i.e. The College of St. Thomas in St. Paul, Minnesota) in Counseling Psychology I don't take kindly to "them" telling me how many components there are to any behavior nor do I like it when "they" tell me what I do or do not have control over. Besides, there are six --not four, but six-- components to any behavior and if I have to argue every single point then I'll get discouraged and help "them" fulfill "their" prediction of the (un)likelyhood of me winning at the diet game. Besides further, there are some limits. This dieting and the need to respond to these (fun) weekly faxes is taking some time and I do have another life that I do have to tend to.
So my textbook answers follow, as does the conlusion to that Stephen King novel we started a few paragraphs back.
Week #2 Answers
Protein Power Review, FYI
Temptation vs. You (page 212)
Name Gary
Fill in the Blanks and fax back to me on Tues. Mar. 16 along with your Weekly Progress Report for Week 2.
1. The four components of any behavior are--
the physiological, the feeling, the thinking and the doing.
2. Of these four components, the one you have complete control over is the doing and partial control over the thinking .
2. Seeing and smelling your temptation (in this case MAPLE doughnuts Gary) starts your physiology working and the following changes in your body occur:
GI tract starts preparing for the incoming temptation, your pancreas releases a little squirt of insulin in preparation (along with your whole being) for consumption of the little temptress.
3. We must not let our physiological and feeling components run over our thinking and doing components.
4. We can gain control of a tempting situation by:
walking away from it and/or by getting involved in some other activity
5. A temptation I'm frequently confronted with that I consistently control is:
feeling hungry
6. And the way I control it is:
drink water
...Pamela, I have more to say on this topic but I don't really have the time to say it right now. The book is actually pretty good on what it does say and gives you an adequate amount of information that you can use. fact is, unbeknownst to me at the time (I just read page 212 today), I did "use" it the first week of the diet.
I was out to the Mall of America on Sunday of that first week to return some slacks to Norstroms. Inside the mall I had to walk about a block to get to Norstroms and on the way there I was immediately overwhelmed with the aroma of Karmelcorn. My knees damn near buckeled but I managed to make it inside Norstroms and was safe. The waffing, aromatic oders did not follow me into the store. So I forgot about it and the fact that I'd have to retrace my steps to get back to my car.
I went to the men's department and gave them my slacks to take back. To my little bit of a surprise --I had bought them (actually Mary did) the week before our vacation which was almost a month and a half ago now-- they took them back with no hassel and didn't even ask me why I was returning them (they were too big and I knew they were going to get "bigger").
Anyway.
I then turned and left and within moments I was back into the mall. I had forgotten what was there and immediately was hit with the gently floating-on-air aromas of Karmelcorn. It was as if each individual kernel of Karmelcorn in my minds eye had been hand dipped in a bowl of liquid carmel and then individually air-brushed dry by some artist who had absolutely nothing better to do then to make each and every kernel a piece of art.
I started thinking, "I should have some of that." Then I quickened my pace. Then I felt, why not. I think maybe I could, a little wouldn't hurt. I quickened some more. Then, I felt like I was in somekind of a Sesame Street skit: the Karmel corn started chasing me down the mall. I looked around and there was absolutely no one to help me and no place to hide--THE AROMAS WERE EVERYWHERE! People to help me?, forget it, there were even a couple of "them" EATING KARMELCORN. I paniced and looked for an exit.
I don't see one, it should be right here. I hope I didn't take a wrong turn out of Nortstroms, there ain't no way in hell I could make it all the way around this mall. Just as I was about to return to Nordstrums for safety and to get my bearings, two kernels, like two guards protecting their mistress, placed their hands on my shoulders and per her orders they grabed me and started dragging me towards the Karmelcorn Store. Just as I was thinking, "oh well what's the use its no big deal what's the worst that could happen", I spotted the exit. I shook loose and damn near broke out into a run but there were too many people mulling around and I didn't want to alam them, so I just hurried it a bit faster.
Fortunately for me I did, because I managed to escape those pursuing kernels and leave behind a very seductive temptress at the same time. In fact as I turned back from the sidewalk just outside the Malls doors I saw her trying to wave me back in. I couldn't hear what she was saying --the exit doors were closed-- but through the glass I could read her moist, senuous (albeit, silicone injected) lips as they expressed the thought: "Just buy a really small box and eat one, maybe two at the most hand fulls and then throw the rest away. So what if you'd be wasting a little money, it will tase really really good."
Feeling a little bit like Rocky, I turned my back on the glass doors and headed for my car.
Like I said I do have more to say on this topic, but I don't have time to say it right now.
Do I know WHO my opponents are?
Yes, I am beginning to see...