gdeering.com

Gary's Venns

Not Zen, but Venn. Venn and the Art of Person Maintenance.

More writing / Jesse Watch 10/2/99

Jesse Watch 10/2/99

Jesse Watch 10/2/99

COMMENTARY

October 2, 1999

(Submitted to the Minneapolis Star Tribune 10/4/99 for publication on Commentary page ___ published)

Dear Op Ed Editor:

If other people's comments cause one to be "mind-full" -- that is to think about things-- then I have to re-evaluate my earlier conclusion that Jesse the Body will never ever never make it to the level of Jesse the Mind.

If other people's comments cause you to question yourself then they are causing you to be mindful, that is, to think. To think, is good.

Jesse's Playboy interview comments about religion (and the "worlds" reaction to it) have caused me to ask myself and to answer no fewer than 6 questions.

  1. What is honesty?
  2. What is religion?
  3. What is Jesse's definition of honesty?
  4. What is Jesse's definition of religion?
  5. What is my definition of honesty?
  6. What is my definition of religion?
First the short answers...
  1. honesty is not lying
  2. religion is all about faith
  3. i don't know
  4. i'm not sure
  5. honesty is never faking reality
  6. religion is a primitive philosophy attempting to satisfy man's need of a comprehensive view of the world and his role in it (contrast this with Objectivism, which is a modern philosophy that satisfies man's need of a comprehensive view of the Universe and his role in it).
...then the long ones.

Honesty is as described and defined by Ayn Rand and given in "The Ayn Rand Lexicon" page 204 (paperback, New American Library, 1986, Edited Dr. Harry Binswanger):

Honesty is the recognition of the fact that the unreal is unreal and can have no value, that neither love nor fame nor cash is a value if obtained by fraud---that an attempt to gain a value by deceiving the mind of others is an act of raising your victims to a position higher than reality, where you become a pawn of their blindness, a slave of their non-thinking and their evasions, while their intelligence, their rationality, their perceptiveness becomes the enemies you have to dread and flee---that you do not care to live as a dependent, least of all a dependent on the stupidity of others, or as a fool whose source of values is the fools he succeeds in fooling---that honesty is not a social duty, not a sacrifice for the sake of others, but the most profoundly selfish virtue man can practice: his refusal to sacrifice the reality of his own existence to the deluded consciousness of others.
"Intellectual honesty [quoting the same Lexicon further p. 205] (involves) knowing what one does know, constantly expanding one's knowledge, and never evading or failing to correct a contradiction. This means: the development of an active mind as a permanent attribute."

Then the applying of all this to myself "answer", by asking a simple question (or two):

Am I the fool (referred to in the first definition above) for voting for Jesse because I believe he is an honest guy and he is proving it in the political realm, a place where traditionally "honesty" is a liability (see Barry Goldwater's lost 1964 Presidential election and virtually every won-an-election-politician since then). Maybe "we" are changing and/or have already changed: that is maybe we do value honesty once again or if not once again then maybe for the first time. (Wouldn't that be something just wonderful?)

So, since I am no longer a pro-religion person (being FOR Objectivism entails being anti-faith) I cannot "empathize" here with those who are still pro-faith.

However, being in a culture that --allegedly-- is interested in empathizing with each other inspite of our differences I ask myself WHAT would Jesse have to say "honestly" in order for me to be so upset with him that I'd reject him totally and completely, once and for all and forever?

Once I asked myself this question the answer came to mind immediately: if he said he "honestly" agreed with those neo-nazi types who believe and assert that the holocaust is a myth, well...

...IF this, then... goodbye you know who forever.

So if --religious people-- you feel the same way about Jesse's religion comments then I now know how you feel. You must feel betrayed and if additionally you voted for Jesse you must feel like you are the fool referred to in the Ayn Rand definition.

If so you have my sincere condolences, feeling the fool is really a hard thing to not evade but if you are honest you'll face it and say such is life's risks and not be too hard on yourself and get on with your life.

(political)Life entails the risk of being taken in. Such is its nature.

But, it's like Ayn Rand said (somewhere): "...you shouldn't damn yourself for not knowing yesterday what you learned today...".

Sincerely yours,

Gary Deering
Webmaster of (among other things) "The Jesse Watch" /www.gdeering.com /POLITICS VENN /pink-boa colored center line in the road to unknown political futures/
adress
City, State, zip

PS
Also remember, feelings are not tools of cognition. Just because --religious people-- your feelings have been hurt it doesn't follow that you have addressed the issue. The issue is --if you read Mr. Ventura's comments in context-- the issue is, is the religious mentality in us all responsible for the fact that INDIVIDUAL rights are not worshipped? And if it is, then religion is wrong --organized or otherwise-- and feelings, like Rush Limbaugh who is one of your own has said on more than one occasion, feelings don't determine an opinions right or wrongness: reason does.

PPS
Out of concern for my own anti-fool protections can someone (preferably a Jesse supporter) please explain to me --in non-contradictory terms-- how Jesse can be for the Minnesota tobacco suit and also for the self-sufficiency virtues inherent in a free-market, laissez-faire capitalistic system? If self-sufficiency means earning an honest buck or if not this then at minimum of earning a buck honestly how can "Minnesota" take a tobacco company's money? What did Minnesota do to EARN it?

FPS
I just discovered last night (10/3/99) on TV that Jesse per Jesse believes in god. That his "religion" is private, very private. He can practice it at the lake or while eating cake or trying to bake --that is, his is a Dr. Seuss type of religion. Shit Jesse by your own words you have reconfirmed that my opening statement is true not false. I tried to give you the benefit of the doubt and to defend your aspiring to the new "the mind" moniker but by your own words you made it the falsehood that it is. The truth is, ultimately ALL aspirants to the higher reaches of mind come to a fork in the road and they must choose which way to go. Both forks look like they go up but in reality only one does, the other one leads back down to the bottom -- how bottom depends on many things way beyond the scope of this Commentary. The road to the top is the one marked: reason, not the one marked faith.