gdeering.com

Gary's Venns

Not Zen, but Venn. Venn and the Art of Person Maintenance.

Politics / Jesse the Body for Pres and Limbaugh the Bully for VP

Jesse the Body for Pres and Limbaugh the Bully for VP

Jesse the Body for Pres and Limbaugh the Bully for VP?

OR
(How to Protect Yourself From Becoming a Cynic)
AND
(Cynicism & Guilt or Self Responsibility & Excitement are
not False Alternatives, they are Choices)
OR
(3 errs and you're out)

April 30, 1999

Even though I like both of these characters I would not vote for such a ticket.

There was a time when I might have.

But not anymore.

Recent assaults on both of these guys has resulted in major damage to their armor. Both assaults came from talk radio and both were self- inflicted.

Jesse's came last month on a local, St. Paul Minnesota, talk show (Joe Soucheray's "Garage Logic" talk show on KSTP AM 1500) and Rush's came just the other day on his own talk show.

As to whether either or both of these assaults and lost battles will cause me to become a cynic I can say for sure: No, neither will.

As to which of the two personalities sustained the most damage I can't say with as much certainty, but I suspect Rush's was more severe.

Jesse 's was less severe because it could be re-cast in a humorous light --and this I did do on my website: www.gdeering.com. If you go there you can see for yourself. Once there, click on the feather-boa pink center line located in the middle-of-the-road on the pictorial Venn that you get after you Enter the Site and click on the POLITICS Venn. Do this and read my Jesse Watch of 3/13/99. That "watch" talks --if not lovingly, then at least-- 'likenly of Jesse the Body wanting to be Jesse the mind but that he has such a long way to go that the wish for him getting there is just that: a wish. Since wishes do not a reality make, suffice it to say, Jesse probably isn't going to live up to my expectations, but so be it. As my purpose in existing is to live up to my own expectations not others, so Jesse's is to live up to his own expectations, not mine. Because of this, Jesse's shortcomings --even though I voted for him-- are not enough to turn me into a cynic.

As to Rush H. Limbaugh the 3, I am not so forgiving. Rush almost (but not quite, but almost) has the capability to turn me into a cynic. I pride myself on the thought that no one but no one --not even my favorite professional intellectuals-- could succeed in turning me into a cynic. But, Rush --who isn't even my favorite-- makes me think about cynicism and the danger of becoming a cynic. I know that this is a fear of all professional intellectuals regardless of the particular 'ism or 'ology that they are professional at. By this I mean, I as a middle class mind am influence-able by the Professional Intellectuals within my culture and they always get hopping up and down concerned when some demagogue comes along who is especially adept at cashing in on the philosophic road-beds that they --the current professionals-- and their philosophic ancestors have spent years and/or --in religions case-- centuries prepping and maintaining. Some upstart demagogue comes along and paves over these pre-existing roadbeds with his own "highway" and reaps the rewards as sole owner of a rather large and well traveled toll road. The "tolls" in this instance are in the form of "time slot" advertising dollars paid to the radio station that hosts the particular demagogue and from which the particular demagogue-employee collects their wages. I can't say for absolute sure, but I suspect a few years and/or decades back some religious professionals probably felt this way about C.S. Lewis in the same way some Objectivist professionals today (probably) feel about Rush Limbaugh.

Anyway, Rush's April 14, 1999 radio show wasn't the first time I didn't like his approach to dealing with callers. He erred once several years back when he had on what sounded to be an extremely intelligent 19 year old girl. Unfortunately, I don't remember the particular topic they were discussing that day but the girl had Rush on the run. And the only way Rush was able to "beat" her, that is to "win" the argument was to opt for that 5% time (or is it 2 1/2%, I forget whether he claims 95% or 97 1/2% error free monologues) when he conveniently abandons his otherwise pretty good intellectual honesty for the venue of ... intimidation. Rather than admit that he might be wrong, Rush chose a different path. He paused for a moment and asked her, her age (she did sound young). Then after she responded innocently and in the spirit of rational discourse Rush proceeded to intimidate her by making some direct BS reference to the fact that she was "only" 19 and "obviously" hadn't lived long enough to know the real meanings of things and it was too bad but this all just meant that she was wrong and that he Rush was right.

Rush erred again on April 14th, 1999.

How I even heard this particular show is a mystery (to me). I don't listen that much anymore.

But on April 14th I was listening.

I didn't even hear the beginning of the guy-caller named Ben. I just caught Rush's comments about it after the very very last line where Ben was saying something about Ayn Rand and her description about unselfishness.

Anyway, Rush started his predictable monologue against Ayn Rand. For awhile he even purposely mis-pronounced her name, but eventually he said it right: Ayn as in mine, Ayn Rand it goes with Rush is a person who does not believe in god and therefore her ideas are wrong because of it. His "reasoning" is this:

Ayn Rand says:

All men are mortal.
Socrates is a man.
---------------------
Therefore, Socrates is mortal.

To which Rush says, this couldn't possibly be true because Ayn Rand does not believe in god.

And before the seconds hand on my classic cars clock can repeat one revolution Rush has a woman caller on the line who gives him moral support for their mutually shared vision of religions role in their respective, albeit flawed, epistemology. And my criticism here is not one of the blind-leading-the-blind but quite the contrary: it is one of the fully "seeing" refusing --like the proverbial monkeys who volitionally place their hands over their own eyes-- who freely refuse to cock their head to one side or the other and simply look around their religious books directly at reality with their own eyes. For the life of me I do not know why religious people are so afraid of reality. If it is no more complicated than that they are simply afraid I understand this, I used to be a god-believer and know first hand the need to distort reality that religion demands. But for the truly honest, fear is not a good enough reason to not reason. In fact, reasoning in the face of fear is one of the things that separates the men from the boys --epistemologically speaking that is.

By (real) men versus boys I mean, reason worshippers versus faith worshippers.

If real men use reason to obtain knowledge of the world, why do those who use faith think it produces knowledge? The intellectually honest answer is:

Faith does not produce knowledge. Knowledge, ultimately --like that on the tree of knowledge-- is evil. Faith produces the "good", which --"ultimately"-- is the non-evil, which in this case is the non-knowledge produced by faith.

And the circle is closed. The rational conclusion here is inescapable: pro-faith is anti-knowledge.

This being the case I have one final question related to this area: In a society dominated by religious sympathizers (recent statistics say that more than 60% of the people in the U.S. view themselves as religious) why is any one surprised that that society's Public School System tends to produce minds that are anti-intellectual? As one piece of evidence for the anti-intellectual charge I offer the recent out burst here in the State of Minnesota against its St. Paul Pioneer Press newspaper for the story they broke last month about the University of Minnesota's Gopher basketball program. On the eve of the "big game" (March Madness) the Pioneer Press printed the story about the Minnesota Gophers and their reliance --if not yet proven dependence-- on academic cheating as the means of maintaining a viable/pretty competitive basketball team. The outburst against this news story came from a populace led by none other than the Governor of the state: Jesse the Body Ventura. This "group" of "Public School Educated" and "concerned" citizens did everything they could to squelch the Pioneer Press journalists who had the guts to print the truth. And the truth here isn't just the facts of the case but also the unstated premise that sports is so important that it justifies academic cheating. And please note, the word "academic" has to be added because no real man, woman or child on the face of Minnesota would ever dare, for one split second, to condone cheating in sports. But "academic" cheating --so as to keep the really good players playing-- probably is ok and may even be required. Required, that is, because: the State is so infested with hypocrites that it becomes a necessary thing to do. Besides, THEY've always done it that way.

If this isn't anti-intellectualism of some-kind, you tell me what it is.

Actually, I have two questions. The other one is this: What do you call those of us who not only survived the school camps but who also emerged --that is, popped up somewhere in adulthood-- as worshippers of reason? If you are one and have not yet done so, allow me the honor:

in as smart and as sharp a military style salute that I can muster, I raise my right hand to you and say:

"Sir! Hero, Sir!

And whether you be male or female, I say the same thing."

Having said the foregoing, I'm not going to go that deeply into Rush's promise of a half dozen or so years ago when he said on the air that he made a conscious choice not to discuss religion on his show. Why is it that the only time I have ever heard him get into religion at all is when something about Ayn Rand comes up? Is it because in spite of his status as a professional intellectual he is afraid for himself, let alone for his flock of lesser mortals? I don't usually think of Rush as a scaredy cat. But, hey why doesn't he pick on someone his own size? Maybe he should challenge Dr. Peikoff or some other of the Objectivist Pros to debate him on his show about the merits or lack thereof of religion. Does he not do it because he's a bully? As a bully he'd rather have total and complete control over his callers so that in most non-fundamentals where it is relatively safe to be intellectually honest -- that is 95% of the time -- he can so be but in that other fundamental-where-it-really counts 5% of the time he can become a modern day equivalent of a Judas and before that classic clock rotates once let alone twice he can opt out of the minds need to be intellectually honest ALL of the time, 100% of the time... or as damn close to it as a body-mind can get. And even though, technically speaking for myself, Rush has only erred twice he is on dangerous ground: What's that saying? thrice and you're out?.

Anyway, though I am saddened I am not cynical. Each and everyone of us has to figure out how to use the apparatus nature has given us and that we call our consciousness. This is a fundamental fact that never, ever changes: cave men had to do it and so do we and so will Tomorrow-Man: We have to design and build within our own mind the way in which we DO and Will validate our own knowledge of the world...of the world of matter and energy and of the world of people. And whether Ayn Rand believes in god or not doesn't have a damn thing to do with it. Reality IS real and we as human beings who are the possessors of reason and volition are capable of denying that fact. If we couldn't deny it we couldn't have volition.

We can turn our backs on reality. But we shouldn't.

As it is my choice, so it is yours.

===============

Gary Deering, 4/30/99
Middle class mind aspiring for hire
City, State, zip

P.S.
Can somebody out their please tell me why religious people are such chicken .... things... when it comes to rationally discussing Objectivism? Is it because Objectivism teaches that reason is superior to faith? Or is it that religious people don't dare question the authoritarianism of their own beliefs? Or is it that their religion causes them to be...scaredy-cats?