gdeering.com

Gary's Venns

Not Zen, but Venn. Venn and the Art of Person Maintenance.

Recreation / APPENDIX E

APPENDIX E

APPENDIX D:

Man is the Measure of All Things

Immanuel Kant said what?

First of all it wasn't Kant it was Protagoras and second of all it wasn't Protagoras who gave his old dictum new meaning, it was the Modern Day Philosopher, Ayn Rand.

Ayn Rand, the Objectivist Philosopher, said: "...Man is the measure of all things ... man has to be the measure because he has to bring everything in the Universe within the realm of the knowable to himself" and in so stating she rendered obsolete nearly every non-objective Philosopher from here to Plato. Such a backwards line up of outdated Philosophers includes but is not limited to Immanuel Kant. Immanuel Kant is the influential German Philosopher from the 18th century whose philosophy accounts for more than half of the "reasoning" that goes on in our (American) culture.*

Immanuel Kant, the Philosopher of Pure Reason, said: "man cannot see true reality because he has a mind that processes reality...". If one were to write a book about Kant and title it "Kant in a Nut-Shell", it could consist entirely of one Ayn Rand line: Kant's pure "reason" is this: "man cannot see because he has eyes". To which a personified culture, a Forest Gump culture could say if it wanted to: "I 'see', Kant is as wrong as wrong can be.*

Protagoras the First Greek Sophist Philosopher and originator of the "...man is the measure of all things..." phrase, meant the phrase in a subjective way not in an objective way. He meant it to mean that your consciousness creates reality, not that reality is an absolute that exists independent of your mind and that your mind's job is to identify reality. That is, he did not mean it in the same way the Objectivists of today mean it.

The Objectivist use of the concept that "man is the measure of all things" means that man relates everything he comes across to his own level of preception and experience and that this is good and proper and since this fact of so relating is the way it is it is the way we should do it.

For example, you may very well be relating right now your "experience" of reading my words here to your other experiences of reading about dieting ideas by asking yourself this question: "what the hell does this have to do with dieting?".

To which the proper answer is: everything.

You will not succeed at weight loss dieting and control until and unless you understand yourself enough to know HOW you think. That is, to know HOW you personally process your observations and knowledge of the facts of the world and draw conclusions about those observations and facts.

Note, once you do know yourself this well you still are not guaranteed success at dieting because success per se is not guaranteeable. Failure is guaranteeable, but success is not. Success, like life itself is conditional: it depends on meeting all the particular conditions required to succeed at the particular endeavor you are trying to succeed at.

So, failure at weight control is guaranteeable and probably explains why 95% of the people who loose weight by dieting eventually gain it all back.

The reason for such a high failure rate could be that an inordinately large percentage of people don't understand what it is they are doing, what their real motives are and what an awsome responsibility it is to take responsibility for the self, be it physically and/or philosophically-psychologically. It is a terrible, frightenting thing to do because if I am wrong I cannot blame someone else for my failure and even worse than this, if I am wrong I could pay the ultimate price, that is I could die as a consequence of my own wrong choices and actions. To this extent, fear of self responsibility is a rational fear.

"C'est la vie" though, should be the response here. If this "that's life" response isn't your response, if you are not the type of person who wants to accept responsibility for your self, then your chances of winning at the diet game are ... zero.

And further, if this is really the case for you, you should not be spending your precious time on trying to diet, you should rather be spending it on trying and succeeding at understanding your self. Specifically, you should be spending time understanding and figuring out what your own particular, personal thinking m.o. is.*

If , however, you do accept responsibility for your self then your chances of winning at the diet game go up precipitously. But remember, acceptance is not success. Success requires that you also find the right diet for you and since you are a human being this means the right diet for human beings as well as the one that accounts for the individual differences that include the individual that is you.

Because your body is the epitome of robust "engineering" design there is much latitude in the kinds of things you can put in it. Granted, some things are better than others but excluding poison (the "ultimate" dieuretic) as an "option" there are numerous, albeit limited, different diets (19 to be exact, see Chapter 1) that could work for you, qua human being, qua individual trying to win the diet game.

I would like to to be able to say here that most people do understand themselves well enough to be a winner in the diet game, but the fact of the 95% recidivism rate (assuming for sake of discussion that it is a legitimate statistic) does loom rather large on the horizon. It is rare to get statistics this high. It is almost a cause-effect statistic, that is it is almost 100% and so one has to wonder, why is it so high and what is its cause?

It is a fact that cannot go unnoticed: Since human beings are winners, why do so many of them lose at the diet game?

My theory is that the reason most people fail at weight control dieting is because they do not accept responsibility for themselves at a psychological depth that is not reachable by slogans and cliches but only by ideas. Self responsibility is real, it is serious and it is something that only a self can do. Here's a cliché: I can't do it for you. Here's an idea: self responsibility is not a choice, your only "choice" in the matter is whether you accept it or reject it. If you accept it you are matching the reality of your nature and needs and if you reject it you are rejecting your self at a very deep, fundamental level and will pay a price for it. If you are a self-responsibility-rejector, my "sympathy" for you is this: C'est la vie.

Here's another cliché: be careful of what you want, you might get it.

Here's another idea: it did not take me 10 years to quit smoking, it took me 10 years to want to quit smoking.

And yes, it is true I don't view smoking as addictive anymore than I view "wanting" as addictive. To call "wanting" addictive is to be a Kantian-Religious thinker.

Oh really? Where the hell did this come from? You can't do this. Where's your basis for introducing "Religious" thinker?

It is here, I am it: I was born and raised "Christian", specifically Lutheran and as such I know first hand what it means to

    • NOT be a doubting Thomas but to HAVE faith,
    • (if this doesn't encourage pseudo self esteem I don't know what does, especially when you consider that "authentic" self esteem is what it is that you get from making "reason" your master.)
    • To believe Jesus loves me, this I know, BECAUSE "The Bible" tells me so
    • (if this isn't an epistemological issue I don't know what is, especially when you realize that the way your "reasoning" should go is: BECAUSE REALITY "says so" and I can see it.)
    • Jesus "produced" wine from a rock by hitting it with his rod (
    • if this along with how many other "miracles" I can't count doesn't make you think that reality is not an absolute I don't know what could.)

It is true that a Christian may very well not be a prototype for ALL religions but a true Christian is.

And a true Christianis a person who accepts ideas based on faith not reason, with faith defined to mean "absense of evidence". If you are a Christian, before you allow yourself to escape this definition by adding a qualifier please note that blind faith means: drawing conclusions "in opposition to the evidence". For example, the Jury on the O.J. Simpson murder trial were operating on a "degree" of faith that went all the way. Which is to say, all the way up to and including blind faith. If you doubt the danger of faith in your every day thinking, the O.J. Simpson Case should give you something to think about because it shows very explicitly just how unjust faith can be and almost always is. I say almost but not quite 100% here because in the final analysis reality is real and even faith can't change this fact. Faith can try to conceive of reality as an illusion but if it doesn't abort such efforts the best it can hope for is still born ideas. Justice is Reality's child and knowing that this is so is Reason's achievement.

Kantians say you cannot know BECAUSE you are a human being and Christians say one way around this is to accept and use faith as the means of knowing. (Presummably Christians want to know and Kantians don't.)

And I also know first hand of where I speak about Kant from my own Public School Education experience. Because of that experience, I spent as much time unlearning after the fact of it as I did learning during it. And I include my Bachelor's of Aeronautical Engineering Degree from MIT* and my Masters of Arts in Counseling Psychology Degree from The College of St. Thomas in St. Paul, Minnesota in with my traditional K thru 12 "public education" experience.

Consequently, I know what it means to mouth deceptive phrases like:

    • it works in theory but not in practice
    • all property is theft
    • you can't be certain of anything, what's the matter with you, weren't you awake during your Physics class when they were discussing Heisenbergs "UnCertainty Principle"?
    • you can't know anything because whatever the "experts" say today will be changed tomorrow, didn't Einstein change Newton? hell, some even say Einstein contradicted Newton (even though he didn't "they" still say it because they want to promote their agenda that says "faith" is superior to "reason" and "we" can "prove" it by proving at every opportunity that man --the reasoning animal-- cannot know anything.
    • )

The best way I know of to overcome --if you are a person (like me) who has (had) a need to overcome-- either your Kantian roots or your Religious roots or both your Kantian & Religious thinking roots is to spend as much time as is required to define your key terms and concepts. And you "define" them by referring first and foremost to reality, that is to the reality of your own first hand experience in the world and then if need be turn to the dictionary for help and then to your own final, objective, integrated definition of that which you are trying to define in accordance to the facts you observe first hand in reality. That is, according to the facts and figures as you measure them in reality.*

For example, "dieting", what does it mean, what is its definition?

"Dieting is measuring the quanity and quality of that which you eat and the non-automatized manner in which you eat it".

At least that's what I did on the "Protein Power" diet.

I lost 7 lbs the first week, 4 pounds the second week and during the wee hours of one of the mornings during my 15th week I reached my goal/OWL weight loss of 31 pounds. As of this date (near December 1999, 24/156ths or almost 1/5th of the way to "forever") I have maintained this weight loss for almost 6 months.

MORE…

TO BE WRITTEN…

AS TIME MARCHES ON...

...TOWARDS...

...FOREVER...


 
(that is, towards our 3rd Anniversary date: 3/02/02) (RECREATION/Go on a diet/The Diet Game/Appendix D OR BACK)

Notes

  1. Since Kant's way of thinking fuels --via John Dewey one of Kants conduits and leader of The Progressive Education Movement in the U.S., a Movement that rejected memorizing basic facts in favor of demonstrating that the erroneous principle: emotions ARE tools of cognition is not erroneous-- fuels America's Public School System. And since more than 90% of the people who get any kind of formal education beyond pre-school get it from the Public School system it is a "safe" bet to conclude that more than 50% of our countrymen are Kantian thinkers.

    For example, Kantians would not disagree that the phrase, "the road to hell is paved with good intentions" is a legitimate phrase because it contains "some" truth. In applying the modern philosophical view of concepts I do not agree that a valid concept can contain "half truths". Instead, I say that a valid concept is one that contains all truth and no falsity. That if something contains "some" truth, "an element" of truth then it also contains "some" falsehoods. That falsehood is your minds evidence that the concept is invalid and should be changed. To make falsehood an accepted part of your validating process is the road to hell... to the hell of blind faith (for definition of "faith", see p. 4 this Appendix). Do not count yourself amongst these travellers. The next time you hear yourself say, or think: "it" has some truth, let that fact alone be a
    red flag to your mind and don't take the flag down until you have thought more about the "it".

    Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh. ↩ back
  2. But your culture does not say it, so it is up to you to take care of yourself here in the thinking arena. Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh. ↩ back
  3. Objectivists and Biocentric Psychologists (see Appendix E) call your thinking m.o. your psycho-epistemology and define it as: the operation of your volitional, conscious mind and its interaction with the automatic operations of your subconscious mind. Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh. ↩ back
  4. University of Minnesota's Institute of Technology, Minneapolis, MN campus. If you thought more and now less of my ideas after discovering that my use of "MIT" does not mean the commonly accepted, prestigious world renouned "Massachuset's Institute of Technology" you have one more step to take to understand your own psycho-epistemology better. And that step is this: are you an authoritarian thinker or do you differentiate between authoritarian (i.e., x is true BECAUSE so 'n so says so) and authority?(i.e., x is probably true BECAUSE so 'n so says so AND if I can trace the steps myself or at least a significant portion of the steps myself back to their roots in reality to demonstrate-prove the assertion then yes, I agree x is true).

    Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh.

    ↩ back
  5. To do this successfully it does help to have some formal definitional rules, but for starters you only need three. First your definition has to have a specis, that is a larger group to which it belongs. Secondly it has to have differentia, that is things that separate it from other members of the larger group and thirdly the definition has to pertain non-contradictorily to ALL applicable members in your mind. Then as your knowledge grows so can your definitions and future ones won't automatically contradict your present ones. In fact they will simply make them better, that is more accurate, more precise as they are suppose to do. Be sure to click your Browser's BACK button to get back to the text from whence you cometh. ↩ back