gdeering.com

Gary's Venns

Not Zen, but Venn. Venn and the Art of Person Maintenance.

Recreation / APPENDIX E: The Pleasure Principle Revisited B. F. Skinner said what?

APPENDIX E: The Pleasure Principle Revisited B. F. Skinner said what?

APPENDIX E:

The Pleasure Principle Revisited

B. F. Skinner said what?

First of all it wasn't Skinner it was Freud and second of all it wasn't Freud who gave his Principle real meaning, it was the Modern Day Psychologist, Dr. Nathaniel Branden.

Dr. Branden, the Biocentric Psychologist, said: "...pleasure is a profound psychological need..." and by such thinking he rendered obsolete nearly half of traditional, mainstream psychology. That is, he single handedly corrected the half dominated by Freud and Skinner.

Freud, the Psychoanalytic Psychologist, said: "...man has a need to die…" That is, Freud invalidated Freud via a self-contradiction. "Needs" are conditions of life not death.

Skinner, the Behaviorist Psychologist, said: "...consciousness is a myth...". That is, Skinner invalidated Skinner by employing an axiomatic concept in an attempt to destroy an axiomatic concept. That axiomatic concept is: "Consciousness is conscious". If consciousness is not conscious, then there is no one around to "grasp" Skinner's "assertion". That is, by what means --if not consciousness-- does Skinner expect me or anyone to "grasp" his assertion that there is no such "thing" as consciousness? To pretend that this last question has an answer is a mistake. That mistake is called: Behaviorism.

As pointed out by Dr. Branden, because Behaviorism rejects consciousness they have to reject "data" of consciousness.

All sensory information is "data" to a consciousness. So are the sensations of "pleasure and pain" data to consciousness.

Since pleasure is real and it is a profound psychological need and food is (one) source of pleasure it isn't that big a leap to conclude that if we are in trouble because of food we should look first to our own psycho-epistemological (see Appendix D) relationship to pleasure in our own personal lives. For example, Am I for pleasure or am I anti-pleasure? Am I for others pleasure but not my own, or vice versa? Do I think all or almost all pleasure is a sin? Is self-sacrafice more important to me than pleasure? Your serious, thoughtful answers to these and similar questions will help you figure out foods relationship to pleasure in your own life. For example, if you are a strong willed self-sacraficer then maybe --since food is such a basic need, then maybe-- even you can't make food a sin and on some level are "saying" to yourself: "Thank god I got at least ONE source of pleasure."?

The Second Place to look is in foods relationship to your sense of control or what the modern day Biocentric psychologists would call: your sense of efficacy.

Efficacy in fundamental psychological terms means how well you have learned how to use your innate capacities to satisfy your innate needs. How well you actually do this in regard to producing your own happiness determines your felt sense of worthiness. If you are pretty happy you are pretty worthy and if you are pretty worthy you are pretty happy.

Efficacy and Worth are pretty important psychological values.

Pleasure follows both, pain follows their absense. That is psychological pleasure and pain do. Physical pleasure and pain are different: they flow like this: physical pleasure flows from the artistic satisfaction of innate needs and physical pain from the active or inactive deprivation and/or attempted destruction of these same needs.

The important thing to grasp here is that human beings have psychological needs as well as physical needs and that "pleasure" is one of the psychological needs and the need of efficacy is another. These are needs in the same sense as are food and oxygen needs.

However, if you are a male fresh out of 20th Century America you may need to first grasp that since men are human beings they too have needs because human beings have needs. Have, that is, in the fundamental sense of "need denial does not a (real) man make".

I don't mean to be sexist here and even though I adhere to the premise that says "statistics are not a valid way to validate knowledge", statistically speaking American women accept that they have needs moreso than do American men. (The cultural reasons for this and the ethnic differences as to particular forms of need denial as pertains particularily to men are beyond the scope of this book. Note that women may very well have some cultural messages also to deny certain types of needs but thanks to womens lib they have been dealt with and written about rather extensively over the past couple of decades and if you are a man you might say, to a boringly long extent. When is it going to be men's turn to be allowed enough time to think about needs and to pursue authentic happiness in their one and only life here on this planet while they actually live? I suspect if women have their way for as long into the future as they have had it in the past the correct answer here is: never.)

Regardless of your sex however, if you are a person who is experiencing difficulty in either loosing weight to get to your OWL weight or in maintaining your weight loss or in both then you should look to foods relationship to pleasure and/or efficacy in your own personal day-to-day life.

If you do you may discover that, cultural messages notwithstanding, as a human being you have volition and can use it to understand your self's problems and strengths and then use it to leverage your strengths to solve your weight problems. And in particular here, use it to solve your "eating" problems.

(RECREATION/Go on a diet/The Diet Game/Appendix E OR BACK)